Not Registered? Register Now.

1. My Profile >2. Additional Information

I certify that I am an individual investor.
Yes, WisdomTree Canada can send me emails, online ads and other electronic messages with information about WisdomTree ETFs as well as white papers, marketing information and commentary. I understand that I can withdraw my consent at any time.

WisdomTree Asset Management Canada, Inc.

161 Bay Street, 27th Floor

Toronto, ON. M5J 2S1

canadafeedback@wisdomtree.com

866-893-TREE (8733)

 

By registering, I certify that I have read, understood and agree to be bound by the WisdomTree Terms of Use. I understand that my personal information will be treated in accordance with the WisdomTree Privacy Policy available here.

 

Dividends

What’s Love Got to Do with This Stock Market? Ask TINA

12/02/2019
Jeff Weniger, CFA, Director, Asset Allocation


During the first half of the year, it seemed everyone was grabbing so-called “low-volatility” stocks.

 

Why?

 

The popular “TINA” trade—“There Is No Alternative”—is based on the belief that stocks should be bought because bond yields are so paltry.

 

If you are of a certain age, you got the blog post title’s Tina Turner reference. The Grammy winner’s biggest song, according to me, was “What’s Love Got to Do with It?” If Turner had been asking about this 10-year bull run in stocks—which would have been really cool—the answer would have been “not much.”

 

Despite 17.4% annualized S&P 500 Index returns from the March 2009 lows through October 2019, the sentiment survey by the American Association of Individual Investors (AAII) shows a largely unloved market, as the percentage of respondents labeling themselves “bullish,” “bearish” or “neutral” is a mixed bag. 

 

In figure 1, I divided the proportion of bullish respondents by the total of bulls and bears (cutting out the neutral onlookers). At 54%, the survey is middling. The market isn’t loved, though it isn’t hated, either.

 

Figure 1: American Association of Individual Investors Bulls Divided by Sum of Bulls + Bears

American Association of Individual Investors Bulls Divided by Sum of Bulls Bears

 

In the first eight months of this year, investors bought stocks with abandon. But market leadership was nevertheless dominated for the most part by the staid “minimum volatility” stocks. No-frills sectors such as Utilities, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and Consumer Staples joined this cycle’s momentum sector—Technology—atop the performance board.

 

Until they didn’t.

 

Though momentum-oriented Tech has held strong this autumn, many of the minimum volatility sectors have been troubled since the market’s sector leadership switched on August 27 (figure 2).

 

Figure 2: S&P 500 Index Sector Performance, 2019
SP 500 Index Sector Performance

 

Because “minimum volatility” and “momentum” became synonymous with each other as the former morphed into the latter, the relative breakdown of defensive sectors hit both factor types in recent months. The MSCI USA Momentum Index has been reeling relative to the broad market for a couple of months (figure 3).

 

Figure 3: MSCI USA Momentum Index Minus WisdomTree U.S. LargeCap Index

MSCI USA Momentum Index Minus WisdomTree U.S. LargeCap Index

The new market darling, at least for the last few months, is the Financials sector, much to the relief of investors in value factor funds. The sector has defied threats of Washington “cracking down on Wall Street,” beating the S&P 500 Index by more than 5 percentage points since the August 27 leadership switch from momentum to value stocks.

 

Russell’s factor indexes are in figure 4. To the momentum factor’s credit, it has a robust 2019 Wall Street earnings growth estimate. But soon, I believe, savvy investors will try to steal a march on 2020 expectations. The consensus has the Russell 1000 Momentum Factor Index’s earnings growing 10.6% next year—only a tad bit higher than the 8.5% expected for the Russell 1000 Value Index. But the former is trading for 20.4x next year’s earnings estimate, a 6-point premium over its value counterpart. Is it worth it?

 

Figure 4: Street Consensus, Russell Indexes

Street Consensus Russell Indexes


Read More
Dividends, Equity


Previous Post Next Post

REGISTER TO RECEIVE BLOG ALERTS

Already registered? Please log in to sign up for blogs.


I certify that I am an individual investor.

WisdomTree Asset Management Canada, Inc.

161 Bay Street, 27th Floor

Toronto, ON. M5J 2S1

canadafeedback@wisdomtree.com

866-893-TREE (8733)

 

By registering, I certify that I have read, understood and agree to be bound by the WisdomTree Terms of Use. I understand that my personal information will be treated in accordance with the WisdomTree Privacy Policy available here.